The Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) today hailed the decision by the City of Cincinnati to drop its four-year-old lawsuit against the gun industry, noting that it is long past the time for this wasteful case to be “round-filed.” SAF had urged the city to drop its case several months ago.

“Cincinnati threw in the towel after gun makers challenged the city to substantiate its wild allegations,” SAF Founder Alan Gottlieb noted. “After spending four years to pursue this frivolous enterprise, it is long past time that this lawsuit is round-filed, where it belonged in the first place.

“If nothing else,” Gottlieb continued, “ending the lawsuit so soon after gun makers demanded to see the evidence behind the city’s claims is a strong indication that the lawsuit was nothing but a flimsy sham all along.”

Cincinnati dropped its legal action on the advice of attorney Stanley Chesley, who said the political climate has changed dramatically. The city was also facing the likelihood that its lawsuit would be rendered moot because Congress appears certain to pass legislation prohibiting gun industry lawsuits.

“Long before Congress took up the issue,” Gottlieb observed, “this was a no-win campaign by anti-gunners in Cincinnati, designed only to drain the finances of gun companies. Chesley’s admission that the political climate has changed, apparently making this a tougher case to win in court, should appall Cincinnati voters.

“Cincinnati’s case was always more about political grandstanding than public safety, and city officials knew it,” he said. “As soon as they were challenged to document their claims, they folded.

“Bringing this lawsuit,” he concluded, “was irresponsible and perhaps morally reprehensible because it pretended to offer a financial solution to gun violence, when no such solution exists. Cincinnati can now use the money it had set aside for attorney fees to fund more police overtime, and other genuine, tangible crime-fighting efforts.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *